Pickleballlane is reader-supported. If you click a link on this page and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Article Content
Pickleball’s meteoric rise has fueled a surge in paddle innovation, and two brands consistently dominate the conversation: Selkirk and JOOLA.
Both are trusted by recreational players and pros alike, offering paddles that cater to diverse playing styles.
But which brand is right for you? In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll break down the key differences between Selkirk and JOOLA paddles, focusing on their top models—Selkirk’s LUXX Control Air Invikta and JOOLA’s Perseus Pro IV 16mm—across critical parameters like performance, materials, price, and more.
If you’re a beginner or a tournament player, this guide will help you choose the paddle that elevates your game.
Key Comparison: Selkirk vs. JOOLA
To give you a clear picture, here’s a side-by-side comparison of two premium paddles from each brand:
| Feature | Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta | JOOLA Perseus Pro IV 16mm |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $250 | $279.95 |
| Weight | 7.8–8.1 oz | 8.1 oz |
| Core Thickness | 20 mm | 16 mm |
| Shape | Invikta (elongated) | Standard |
| Face Material | Florek Carbon Fiber | Carbon Friction Surface |
| Core Material | Thikset Honeycomb | Propulsion + Tech Flex Power |
| Grip Circumference | 4.25″ | 4.25″ |
| Handle Length | 5.35″ | 5.5″ |
| Paddle Length | 16.45″ | 16.5″ |
| Paddle Width | 7.5″ | 7.5″ |
| Edge Guard | Aero-DuraEdge Edgeless | Not specified |
| Warranty | Lifetime | 6 months |
| Endorsed By | Jack Sock | Ben Johns |
| Key Features | Expanded sweet spot, unequaled control, ample power, accelerated spin | Explosive power, great spin, tournament-approved, premium feel |
Performance Breakdown
Power
- Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta: Despite its control focus, the LUXX delivers ample power thanks to its 20mm Thikset Honeycomb core and Florek Carbon Fiber face. It’s ideal for balanced players who want control without sacrificing pop for drives or smashes.
- JOOLA Perseus Pro IV 16mm: Rated 10/10 for power by Pickleheads, this paddle is a powerhouse. Its Propulsion + Tech Flex Power core and Carbon Friction Surface make it perfect for aggressive players who prioritize explosive serves and drives.
Winner for Power: JOOLA Perseus Pro IV
Control
- Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta: This paddle shines in control, with a 20mm core that creates a large sweet spot and absorbs pace for precise dinks and resets. Reviews from Pickleball Effect praise its plush, crisp feel, making it a favorite for advanced players.
- JOOLA Perseus Pro IV 16mm: While it scores 8/10 for control, its power-oriented design means it’s less forgiving than the LUXX. It’s better suited for players with strong technique who can manage control themselves.
Winner for Control: Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta
Spin
- Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta: The Florek Carbon Fiber face and ProSpin+ NextGen texture generate excellent spin, particularly for topspin shots like third-shot drops, as noted in Pickleheads.
- JOOLA Perseus Pro IV 16mm: With a 9/10 spin rating, the Carbon Friction Surface excels at gripping the ball for spin-heavy shots. Its multi-step abrasion process enhances spin consistency, per JOOLA USA.
Winner for Spin: Tie (both offer top-tier spin)
Forgiveness
- Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta: The 20mm core and edgeless design create a forgiving paddle with a large sweet spot, ideal for off-center hits. Users on Pickleball Warehouse note its stability and comfort.
- JOOLA Perseus Pro IV 16mm: Rated 8.5/10 for forgiveness, it’s solid but less forgiving than the LUXX due to its thinner 16mm core, which prioritizes power over mishit absorption.
Winner for Forgiveness: Selkirk LUXX Control Air Invikta
Additional Models to Consider
While the LUXX and Perseus Pro IV are flagship models, both brands offer other paddles worth exploring:
| Model | Brand | Price | Weight | Core Thickness | Shape | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanguard Control Invikta | Selkirk | $199 | 7.3–8.1 oz | 16 mm | Invikta | Affordable, control-focused, great for resets |
| Ben Johns Perseus CFS 16 | JOOLA | $249.95 | ~8.0 oz | 16 mm | Standard | Soft, crisp feel, excellent control |
| SLK NEO 2.0 | Selkirk | $60 (set) | 7.5 oz | 13 mm | Standard | Budget-friendly, great for beginners |
| Anna Bright Scorpeus Pro IV 14mm | JOOLA | $279.95 | 8.0 oz | 14 mm | Standard | High forgiveness, low swing weight |
Brand Strengths
Selkirk
- Warranty: Offers a lifetime warranty, one of the best in the industry, covering manufacturing defects (Pickleball Central).
- Manufacturing: Assembled in the USA, supporting local production, as noted in user discussions on Reddit.
- Range: From budget-friendly SLK models to premium LUXX paddles, Selkirk caters to all levels.
- Technology: Features like Florek Carbon Fiber and Aero-DuraEdge Edgeless technology enhance performance (Selkirk Sport).
- Endorsements: Backed by pros like Jack Sock, ensuring tournament-ready quality.
JOOLA
- Professional Endorsements: Sponsors top players like Ben Johns and Anna Bright, lending credibility (JOOLA USA).
- Technology: Innovations like Carbon Friction Surface and Propulsion cores deliver power and spin (The Kitchen).
- Certification: Many paddles, like the 3S series, are UPA-A certified, with plans for dual USAP/UPA-A certification in 2025.
- Variety: Offers paddles for power, control, and hybrid playstyles, with NFC chip-enabled models for warranty registration.
User Insights
User feedback from pickleballlane community are also helpful in highlighting the key differences:
- Selkirk: Praised for power and durability, with a lifetime warranty that’s a major draw. However, some users note grit wear on the face, reducing spin over time, which isn’t covered by warranty.
- JOOLA: Favored for control and feel, particularly for dinking and resetting. Some users report durability issues, and the 6-month warranty is seen as a limitation compared to Selkirk.
Both brands are considered premium, but some players argue they’re overpriced compared to boutique brands like Vatic Pro or SixZero, which offer similar performance at lower costs.
Choosing the Right Paddle
- For Beginners: Selkirk’s SLK NEO 2.0 is a budget-friendly option with a lifetime warranty, making it a safe choice. JOOLA’s entry-level paddles are also solid but lack the same warranty protection.
- For Advanced Players: The Selkirk LUXX is ideal for control-focused players, while the JOOLA Perseus Pro IV suits those who prioritize power and spin.
- For Tournament Play: Both brands are tournament-approved, but JOOLA’s pro endorsements give it an edge in professional circles.
- For Value: Selkirk’s lifetime warranty and US assembly offer better long-term value, while JOOLA’s premium pricing reflects its advanced technology.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Which brand is better for beginners? | Selkirk’s SLK NEO 2.0 is a top choice for beginners due to its affordability ($60 for a set) and lifetime warranty, offering peace of mind. JOOLA’s entry-level paddles are also good but have a shorter warranty. |
| Which brand offers better value for money? | Selkirk provides better value with its lifetime warranty and US assembly, though JOOLA’s advanced technology may justify its higher price for some players. |
| Are Selkirk paddles made in the USA? | Yes, Selkirk paddles are assembled in the USA, supporting local manufacturing and ensuring high quality. |
| Do JOOLA paddles have a good warranty? | JOOLA offers a 6-month warranty, which is shorter than Selkirk’s lifetime warranty and requires registration within 14 days of purchase. |
| Which brand is preferred by professional players? | Both are used by pros. JOOLA sponsors Ben Johns and Anna Bright, while Selkirk is endorsed by Jack Sock, making the choice dependent on your preferred pro’s style. |
Conclusion
Selkirk and JOOLA are titans in the pickleball world, each bringing unique strengths to the court. Selkirk’s LUXX Control Air Invikta excels in control and forgiveness, backed by a lifetime warranty and US assembly, making it a great choice for players who value precision and durability.
JOOLA’s Perseus Pro IV 16mm, with its explosive power and pro endorsements, is perfect for aggressive players seeking tournament-grade performance.
Your choice depends on your playing style, budget, and whether you prioritize long-term value or cutting-edge technology.
Demo both brands if you can, and get ready to elevate your pickleball game in 2025!
Also See: